Old slug from Guyana
November 25, 2009
From: Floris Bennema
Hi,
I am studying species in an 18th century book and ran in to this slug.
It was send to the Dutch author ('in liqour') from Esseqiubo, a Dutch colony in Guyana (South America; West Atlantic)
Locality: Unknown, unknown, Guyana, West Atlantic ocean, 1765, unknown. Length: 3/4 of a thumb (= 2 cm.). Photographer: Martinus Slabber.
According to the author it is a sea slug. In 1970 a Dutch malacologist (van Benthem Jutting) speculated it could be a Umbraculum, but she was doubtful.
Does anyone have an idea?
Thanks
Floris Bennema
f.p.bennema@gmail.com
Bennema, F.P., 2009 (Nov 25) Old slug from Guyana. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/22808Dear Floris,
It would be valuable if you could give me the name of the book and author to include with your message.
The first problem is we have no idea just how accurate the artist [or engraver] was. It certainly could be a snail or slug with a limpet-shaped shell and there are indications it could be Umbraculum, but if the frilly row of papillae are suppose to represent the single gill of Umbraculum, then the papillae should run above the head and tentacles in an unbroken row. Also if you look at some of the photos of Umbraculum you will see that the head and 'snout' are not as in this illustration. Another possibility is another limpet-like slug, Tylodina americana. I don't have any photos on the Forum but have a look at Tylodina corticalis which has a head more similar to the illustration.
The other possibility is that it is some type of limpet. I'm afraid I can't easily identify the 3 pairs of tentacles [a,b,c]. Perhaps they are not accurate? Are shells illustrated in the book? I suspect if it had a shell it would have dropped off in the 'preserving jar' and if it didn't dissolve in the 'liqour' perhaps it was dried and drawn separately?
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Not a volute or nudibranch?
From: Mike Burnett, January 19, 2010 -
Re: Old slug from Guyana
From: Floris Bennema, December 23, 2009 -
Re: Umbraculum laying eggs
From: Leanne and David Atkinson, January 29, 2009 -
Juvenile Umbraculid? from North Sulawesi
From: Hösel, Heidi, October 8, 2008 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from New Zealand
From: Kent Ericksen, December 8, 2006 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from Reunion Island
From: Hugues Flodrops, December 8, 2006 -
Umbraculum from the Gold Coast, Queensland
From: Ian Banks, May 12, 2006 -
Umbraculum umbraculum feeding
From: Leanne & David Atkinson, March 25, 2006 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from Port Stephens
From: Bruce Potter, March 10, 2006 -
Re: An aquarium 'hitch-hiker'
From: Unni Nair, November 18, 2005 -
An aquarium 'hitch-hiker'
From: Unni Nair, November 12, 2005 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from New Zealand
From: Trevor Edward Lochore, December 30, 2004 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from Jervis Bay
From: Sue Newson, November 27, 2003 -
Umbraculum laying eggs
From: Leanne & David Atkinson, April 10, 2003 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from Lord Howe Island
From: W.B. Rudman, January 21, 2003 -
Umbraculum umbraculum from Indonesia
From: Mary Jane Adams , January 6, 2003 -
Umbraculum what?
From: Valda Fraser, December 21, 2001 -
Umbraculum from Sydney Harbour.
From: George Evatt , July 4, 2001 -
Umbraculum laying eggs in New South Wales
From: Peggy Cable, March 11, 2001 -
Anatomy of Umbraculum
From: Bill Rudman, March 11, 2001 -
Umbraculum umbraculum
From: A.Lumnitzer & D.Piotrowska, June 11, 2000 -
Re: Mystery from South Africa
From: Johan Bresler, August 26, 1999 -
Mystery from South Africa
From: Johan Bresler, August 25, 1999 -
Umbraculum from deep water off Australia
From: Bill Rudman, March 25, 1999