Nembrotha chamberlaini from Malaysia?
December 7, 2009
From: Mirjam Broos
Hello Bill,
I really thought we found Nembrotha chamberlaini near Siamil Island, Malaysia (the colour of the gills extends on to the dorsum) but I read on the forum that N. chamberlaini only exists in Indonesia and the Philippines. So is this N. rutilans after all?
Locality: Siamil Island (near Kapalai), Froggy layer, Sabah, Malaysia, 27 september 2009. Photographer: Geert Prast.
best regard,
Mirjam
mirjam.broos@planet.nl
Broos, M., 2009 (Dec 7) Nembrotha chamberlaini from Malaysia?. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/22877Dear Mirjam,
One of the exciting things about scientific discovery is that the written 'facts' are only as good as the last observation. At present this species has only been recorded from Indonesia and the Philippines but as you have found a specimen of N. chamberlaini in Malaysia then we will have to change the books. Most new scientific information expands like this by small steps, but as we have seen quite often on the Forum, our knowledge of geographic distribution of species can sometimes expand across an ocean in just one step.
One problem which is still unresolved though is just how many species there are in this colour group of Nembrotha species. Yours certainly fits the 'typical' colour form, but as to how much colour variation should be included in the species is still a puzzle. Photos such as yours can be very valuable in determining just how variable a colour pattern can be.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding
From: Dr. Carsten Harfmann, December 7, 2009 -
Mating brown & green Nembrotha chamberlaini
From: Kara Miller, September 15, 2009 -
Re: Unicorn Nembrotha chamberlaini
From: Marcel Tanke, September 15, 2009 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini: The ART of laying eggs
From: Marcel Tanke, September 15, 2009 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding [2]
From: Marcel Tanke, August 25, 2008 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding, Philippines
From: Marcel Tanke, July 1, 2008 -
Unicorn Nembrotha chamberlaini
From: Marcel Tanke, June 30, 2008 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding at Komodo
From: Natasja Vandeperre, April 21, 2008 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding on Ascidians (Phillipines)
From: James McMahon, February 28, 2008 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding
From: Mike Krampf, April 18, 2007 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding on an ascidian
From: Paul Osmond, January 19, 2007 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini from Bali
From: Erwin Kodiat, October 7, 2003 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini from the Philippines
From: Yukari Sato, October 5, 2003 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini mating
From: Todd Garthwaite, March 7, 2002 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini from the Philippines
From: Mary Jane Adams, January 22, 2002 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding
From: Terry Gosliner, September 15, 2000 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini feeding
From: Erwin Koehler, September 13, 2000 -
Re: Nembrotha chamberlaini from Indonesia
From: Pete Vogt, April 19, 1999 -
Nembrotha chamberlaini from Indonesia
From: Peter Vogt, February 24, 1999 -
Observations on Nembrotha chamberlaini
From: Erwin Koehler, January 8, 1999 -
Re: Philippines Nembrotha
From: Terry Gosliner, December 16, 1998 -
Re: Philippines Nembrotha
From: Dave Behrens, December 16, 1998 -
Re: Nembrotha chamberlaini
From: Terry Gosliner, December 16, 1998 -
Nembrotha from the Philippines
From: Erwin Koehler, December 12, 1998