Re: Aplysia punctata mating, spawning and variations
October 3, 2007
From: Joao Pedro Tojal Loia Soares Silva
Concerning message #20473:
Dear Bill,
I'm pretty sure the animal with the pink border wasn't Aplysia fasciata. First of all, the parapodia of Aplysia fasciata do not join as "high" as these specimen. Second, they were a lot smaller (A. fasciata specimen observed only two weeks before were +20 cm, compared to less than 10 cm of these) and showing a lot more variation than Aplysia fasciata as I've ever seen.
The animal with the darker spots could be a single small Aplysia depilans but I doubt the others could be A. fasciata (which is a species I'm quite used to watch).
I'm sending a photo taken just a few days before not far away showing a similar congregation of Aplysia fasciata and you'll find they're quite different, even when they have the parapodia "closed" over the mantle one can see they stay separated quite far back. By the way, the A. fasciata were taken with 18 mm focal distance while the A. punctata were photographed with a 50 mm macro.
Locality: Berlengas island, 11 m, Portugal, North Atlantic, 29 July 2007, Rock. Length: Between 20 and 30 cm. Photographer: Joao Pedro Tojal Loia Soares Silva.
Cheers,
Joao Pedro
jpsilva@uwphotographer.net
Silva, J. P., 2007 (Oct 3) Re: Aplysia punctata mating, spawning and variations. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/20526Dear Joao Pedro,
Even thought these are photos of A. fasciata I am putting your message with A. punctata. I am sure you are correct with your identifications. The best way to identify species of Aplysia is to compare them with other species in their natural surroundings. The differences in shape are usually fairly obvious - its just difficult to put the differences into words. And when I have only photos I am usuallu quite hesitant in makling positives identifications - as I was in your earlier message.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Aplysia punctata from the Western Isles, Scotland
From: Lindsay Bradley, October 3, 2007 -
Aplysia punctata mating, spawning and variations
From: Joao Pedro Silva, August 20, 2007 -
Aplysia punctata mating
From: Jim Anderson, August 20, 2007 -
Re: Appetitive behaviour in Aplysia
From: Mark Henry, August 22, 2006 -
Appetitive behaviour in Aplysia
From: Mark Henry, August 21, 2006 -
Markings on Aplysia punctata
From: Mark Henry, August 17, 2006 -
A summer spawn of Aplysia punctata
From: Mark.Henry, August 15, 2006 -
Sea Hare from Lochiver, Northwest Scotland
From: Colin Robertson, March 28, 2006 -
Spanish Sea Hares
From: Sascha Schulz, February 20, 2006 -
Sea Hare from Spain
From: Raul Castro, December 17, 2005 -
Aplysia punctata from Scotland
From: Cherry Welsh, August 19, 2005 -
Juvenile Aplysia from Norway
From: Kåre Telnes, July 30, 2005 -
Aplysia punctata from Croatia
From: Andrej Jaklin, March 4, 2005 -
Aplysia from Croatia
From: Andrej Jaklin, March 4, 2005 -
Age determination of Aplysia punctata
From: Marta K. Soffker, February 18, 2005 -
Aplysia punctata mating
From: Jim Anderson, November 27, 2003 -
Aplysia punctata from French Mediterranean
From: Marina Poddubetskaia, July 19, 2003 -
Aplysia punctata (adult) from French Brittany
From: Marina Poddubetskaia, April 29, 2003 -
Aplysia punctata (juvenile) from French Brittany
From: Marina Poddubetskaia, April 29, 2003 -
Aplysia punctata in aquarium
From: Michael, November 10, 2002 -
Re: commensal bivalve & Aplysia
From: Dr.Stephen R Hoskins, June 18, 2002 -
Re: Commensal bivalve - Sea Hare
From: Dr. Stephen R. Hoskins, June 17, 2002 -
Re: galeommatoidean commensal on Aplysia?
From: Serge Gofas , June 13, 2002 -
Aplysia punctata and commensal? bivalve.
From: Stephen Hoskins, June 8, 2002 -
Aplysia punctata in Germany
From: Peter Gleisenstein , May 31, 2002 -
Aplysia punctata & 'passengers'
From: Dr. Stephen Hoskins, May 16, 2002 -
Aplysia punctata from Portugal
From: João Tojal Silva, April 23, 2002 -
Aplysia punctata defensive mechanism
From: Marilyn Jackson, December 13, 2000 -
What does Aplysia punctata eat?
From: Trevor Shand, August 7, 2000 -
Observations on Aplysia punctata
From: Andy Horton, October 2, 1999