Say it isn't so! Is Berghia dangerous?
November 12, 2001
From: David Fisher
My 55 gal. reef tank is decimated by an Aiptasia infestation. The straw that broke the camel's back was when my tridacnid clam died presumably from stings from adjoing Aiptasia. Realizing that I would have no peace until I rid myself of the pests, I bit the bullet and plunked down $32 for 2 Berghias.
Now I just read that Berghia may prey on more than just the Aiptasia. I have a HUGE LTA with host clown and damsel fish. Will they all co-exist happily?
It's a little late to be asking, but I'd still like to know the answer (or entertain any reasonable guesses).
Thanks in advance.
David
fisherd@cfs.purdue.edu
Fisher, D., 2001 (Nov 12) Say it isn't so! Is Berghia dangerous?. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/5662Dear David,
'Biological control' always has a bit of risk associated with it. In this case, if your slugs are eating Aiptasia then I guess they could eat other anemones. I am not sure what 'LTA' means but your mention of clown fish suggests it may mean 'Large Tank Anemone' or something similar.
Yes there is a chance that your nudibranch might have a go at a large anemone, but I remember reading years ago about a study on the relationships between a population of Stoichactus, which is one of the large anemones, and their commensal clown fish. That study showed that clown fish became very territorial and aggressive towards anything that approached their anemone. Over 18 months, anemones with clown fish had a much better survival rate than anemones without fish, suggesting that the commensal relationship gave the anemone some protection as well. So perhaps your fish will keep your LTA safe. However there is always the possibility that the fish will mortally wound the Berghia in the process. Sounds better than watching tv!
Cheers,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Re: Where to get 'Berghia verrucicornis'
From: Adam Goehner, July 1, 2008 -
'Berghia Breeder'
From: Ben Caruso, February 6, 2008 -
Re: Aeolidiella stephanieae - zooxanthella for orientation?
From: Dene Banger, December 14, 2007 -
Aeolidiella stephanieae - zooxanthella for orientation?
From: Dene Banger, December 11, 2007 -
Berghia verrucicornis?
From: Marshall Doud, August 2, 2007 -
'Berghia verrucicornis' - Captive Life Span
From: Lisa Brown, March 14, 2006 -
Re: Berghia verrucicornis to give away
From: Yvonne Rozsenich, September 5, 2005 -
Anemone eating slugs
From: Carl Fario, August 20, 2005 -
What is the real Berghia verrucicornis?
From: Jimmy, March 25, 2004 -
Berghia in aquarium
From: John Mauro, Jr., January 3, 2003 -
Berghia verrucicornis - where do I get it?
From: Patrizia Bacci, October 18, 2002 -
Berghia verrucicornis - Where?
From: Mafalda N. Madeira, October 10, 2002 -
Berghia sp. in south Atlantic coast
From: Gustavo Duarte, September 14, 2002 -
Aquarium Berghia photos
From: Leslea, June 19, 2002 -
Berghia Help Please
From: Leslea, May 28, 2002 -
Re: More information: fighting Aiptasia
From: Phil C., May 10, 2002 -
More information: fighting Aiptasia
From: Vincent Prasil, May 6, 2002 -
Aiptasia control in open water conditions
From: Vincent Prasil, May 3, 2002 -
Berghia verrucicornis - aquarium culture
From: Steve Kempf, March 9, 2002 -
Aiptasia - help please
From: John D. Bessette, February 15, 2002 -
Re: Desperate search for Berghia
From: Juan Lucas Cervera, January 23, 2002 -
Desperate search for Berghia
From: Thierry Reynier, January 21, 2002 -
Where to get Berghia verrucicornis
From: Tom Kozicki, January 21, 2002 -
Are all Berghias equal?
From: David Fisher, December 6, 2001 -
Berghia from seaslug-vs-aiptasia.ebz.com
From: Carlo Bortolotti, September 7, 2001 -
Buying Berghia verrucicornis &. Aiptasia
From: Michael Bloss, June 18, 2001 -
Berghia intelligence
From: Yvonne Rozsenich , June 16, 2001 -
Berghia verrucicornis to give away
From: Yvonne Rozsenich, June 11, 2001 -
Berghia verrucicornis for sale
From: Luis Doallo, March 23, 2001 -
The identity of Berghia verrucicornis
From: Steven , March 3, 2001 -
Keeping Berghia verrucicornis
From: Yvonne Rozsenich, March 2, 2001 -
Sea Spiders and Berghia
From: Carlos, January 24, 2001 -
Pycnogonids and Berghia verrucicornis
From: Jennifer Whitacre, January 19, 2001 -
Berghia verrucicornis and other sea anemones?
From: Thomas Ipsen, October 7, 2000 -
Aiptasia problems
From: Berndt Nollmeyer , June 7, 2000 -
Buying Berghia verrucicornis
From: Bryan Schroeder, February 26, 2000 -
Aquaculture of Berghia verrucicornis
From: Gary J. Robinson, February 14, 2000 -
Removing Aiptasia from reef tanks
From: Peter Myers, February 7, 2000 -
Berghia verrucicornis for sale
From: Joey Berkley , January 7, 2000 -
Spurilla australis
From: Michael Phan, December 24, 1999 -
Looking to buy a nudibranch...
From: Carrie Clark, December 17, 1999 -
Re: Berghia verrucicornis v. Aiptasia
From: Michele Brown , October 1, 1999 -
Berghia verrucicornis versus Aiptasia
From: Dave Behrens, September 23, 1999 -
Aiptasia-eating nudibranchs
From: Ara Vaporciyan, August 31, 1999 -
The Aiptasia problem revisited
From: Anthony Donovan, August 21, 1999 -
Re: Berghia verrucicornis
From: Karen, July 16, 1999 -
Where can I get Berghia verrucicornis?
From: David, June 20, 1999 -
Can I get Berghia in Europe?
From: Ward Spruyt, February 24, 1999 -
Where do I buy Berghia verrucicornis?
From: Gary Swanberg, October 19, 1998 -
Aiptasia eating nudibranch
From: LEE , August 15, 1998 -
Info about Berghia verrucicornis
From: Michael Phan, July 2, 1998