Hypselodoris bullocki colour group (1)
April 9, 2002
From: Bernard Picton
Hi Bill,
Looking at Hypselodoris bullocki on the Forum I don't see any pictures of the large form of this "species" (colour group?) which I have seen many times in Indonesia. These animals are typically 6cm long, the gills and rhinophores are orange, and spots of background purple/pink colour break through the white marginal band which gradually fades away towards the centre of the mantle. I've seen these animals mating and the large ones I have seen have all been this colour form in Bali, Hoga, and Sipadan Is.
Pictures of this form:
chrbul2 - Kubu, East coast Bali, Mar 1989
chrbul3 - Hoga, SE Sulawesi, October 1997
chrbul4 - NW Bali, March 1996
chrbul5 - Hoga, SE Sulawesi, October 1997
Compare these with the photo of a small form I have sent in a separate message. I'm sure these are different species, perhaps we should take a "precautionary principle" approach with these and consider different colour forms to be a mimicry/colour group until proven otherwise. If you had not started this approach with the "quadricolor" colour group we would never have got to
where we are now; ie. a better understanding of the species involved ;-) !
Looking at the pictures in Debelius there may be as many as six species shown there in my opinion, there is a picture of the small form I describe here (also mating) on the front cover.
Bernard
bernard.picton.um@nics.gov.uk
Picton, B. , 2002 (Apr 9) Hypselodoris bullocki colour group (1). [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/6429
Thanks Bernard,
I am sure you are probably right. I have just continued to 'lump' them together as the "H. bullocki group' in the hope that someone would study them as a group and not see them picked off one by one by people more interested in naming a new species than in understanding what is going on in the group. The problem with the 'one at a time approach' is that someone else is still left to do the real work of sorting out the complex, looking at limits of colour variation etc.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
PS: [I'm sorry to say this is one of the messages that got stuck in the backlog. You will see that since you sent it I have posted a photo of this form from Indonesia from Tony Wu.]
Rudman, W.B., 2002 (Apr 9). Comment on Hypselodoris bullocki colour group (1) by Bernard Picton . [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/6429Related messages
-
Re: Purple sea slug
From: Jason Sanders, March 3, 2009 -
Re: Hypselodoris bullocki - eggs
From: Jim Chambers, June 30, 2008 -
Re: Hypselodoris bullockii? & H. apolegma mating
From: Teresa Zuberbühler, June 4, 2008 -
Re: Hypselodoris bullockii? & H. apolegma mating
From: Reindert Grooters & Mieke Snoek, June 4, 2008 -
Hypselodoris bullockii? and H. apolegma mating
From: Teresa (Zubi) Zuberbühler, April 29, 2008 -
Hypselodoris apolegma? from Indonesia
From: Ken Tucker, August 3, 2007 -
Re: Hypselodoris apolegma feeding?
From: Ann Clear, August 3, 2007 -
Hypselodoris apolegma feeding?
From: Ann Clear, August 2, 2007 -
Re: Hypselodoris apolegma mating
From: Asther Lau, July 20, 2007 -
Hypselodoris apolegma - feeding record [2]
From: Richard Swann, March 19, 2007 -
Hypselodoris apolegma feeding record
From: Richard Swann, March 19, 2007 -
Re: Hypselodoris apolegma with a parasite from Bali
From: Leslie Harris, December 8, 2006 -
Hypselodoris apolegma with a parasite from Bali
From: Mike Krampf, December 7, 2006 -
Hypselodoris apolegma feeding
From: Roberto Sozzani, April 10, 2006 -
Re: Hypselodoris apolegma mating
From: Arief Wiriadinata, November 7, 2005 -
Hypselodoris apolegma mating
From: Mary Jane Adams, October 20, 2005 -
Hypselodoris apolegma feeding
From: Bob Whorton, July 4, 2005 -
Re: Hypselodoris bullocki - feeding and care
From: Mike Cheney, March 19, 2004 -
Re: Hypselodoris bullocki - feeding and care.
From: Mike Cheney, March 18, 2004 -
Re: Hypselodoris apolegma with deformed gills
From: Asther M. Lau, October 3, 2003 -
Hypselodoris apolegma with deformed gills
From: Ray Izumi, August 11, 2003 -
Hypselodoris apolegma from Malaysia
From: Asther M. Lau, July 5, 2003 -
Hypselodoris apolegma from Malaysia
From: Kelvin Tan, February 12, 2003 -
Hypselodoris apolegma
From: Bill Rudman, October 31, 2002 -
Hypselodoris apolegma from west Malaysia
From: Kheong Sann Chan, October 31, 2002 -
Hypselodoris apolegma feeding
From: Kheong Sann Chan, October 31, 2002 -
Hypselodoris apolegma mating
From: Kheong Sann Chan, October 31, 2002 -
Hypselodoris bullocki-apolegma from Malaysia
From: Richard Houghton, July 21, 2002 -
'Risbecia apolegma' from Malyasia
From: Kheong Sann Chan, June 5, 2002 -
Hypselodoris cf. bullocki = Risbecia apolegma
From: Clay Carlson , May 1, 2002 -
Hypselodoris cf. bullocki from Malaysia
From: Kheong Sann Chan, April 27, 2002 -
Hypselodoris bullocki? from Indonesia
From: Tony Wu, April 7, 2001