Risbecia ghardaqana? from the Red Sea
July 24, 2006
From: Kamal El Tawil
Dear Bill,
Here is a beautiful Risbecia from the Red Sea crawling on coral formations. Is it R. pulchella or R. ghardaqana? The difference is still confusing for me. I turned to your message #9625 and my message #14651. Taking into consideration the nine gills on this nudibranch I identify it as Risbecia ghardaqana.
Locality: Maksour Reef, Fury Shoal, Red sea, 18, Egypt, Red Sea, 10 July 2006. Length: 50-60 mm. Photographer: Kamal El Tawil.
please confirm.
best regards,
Kamal
kamal@coralworld.net
El Tawil, K., 2006 (Jul 24) Risbecia ghardaqana? from the Red Sea. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/17209Dear Kamal,
Firstly I am also confused by these two species. If it were not that Gohar & Aboul-Ela (1957) had examined so many specimens and could see clear differences, I would probably have concluded the two were variants of the same species. So I am as keen as you are to find more animals which fit there description of R. ghardaqana. It would also be nice to find egg ribbons of both species, as they note that R. ghardaqana has a white egg ribbon and R. pulchella a red-orange one.
Certainly the small number of gills, and the relatively large yellow spots in your photo, both fit their R. ghardaqana. However they state that the gills in R. ghardaqana are 'non vibratile', that is they don't wave from side to side, and that the front of the mantle doesn't expand into a 'prominent veil'. In your photo the front of the mantle does expand, and the gills certainly look as though they are waving around.
The record on the Forum I am most comfortable with is Barbara Phua's from Thailand #7195. It is a long way from the Red Sea, but it seems the distribution of quite a few species extends across the nthn Indian Ocean from the Red Sea to Thailand. Her animals have few gills, no expanded region at the anterior end of the mantle, and lays a white egg ribbon. I can't be 100% sure, but I think your animal is a relatively small R. pulchella.
Please don't lose interest in this quest. Now that you are familiar with R. pulchella, hopefully when you do find R. ghardaqana, the differences will be obvious.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Re: Risbecia pulchella at rest
From: Ron Velarde, February 24, 2009 -
Risbecia pulchella at rest
From: Valda Fraser, February 16, 2009 -
Risbecia pulchella - Stretching ?
From: Kamal El Tawil, June 6, 2008 -
Trailing Risbecia pulchella from the Red sea
From: Kamal El Tawil, April 9, 2008 -
More Risbecia ghardaqana from Thailand?
From: K. Kalani Patterson, February 5, 2008 -
Re: Risbecia ghardaqana from Hurghada, Egypt
From: Yahia Mokhtar, October 30, 2007 -
Risbecia pulchella from the Red Sea
From: Larry Dupriest, October 30, 2007 -
Risbecia ghardaqana ? from Muscat, Oman
From: Yahia Mokhtar, September 21, 2007 -
Mating Risbecia pulchella from Tofo, Mozambique
From: Natasja Vandeperre, August 24, 2007 -
Risbecia ghardaqana? from Indonesia
From: Grace Wong, August 18, 2007 -
Re: Rispecia ghardaqana? from South Africa
From: Colin Ogden, May 9, 2007 -
Risbecia pulchella from the Red Sea
From: Kamal El Tawil, March 6, 2006 -
Periclimenes imperator on mating Risbecia pulchella
From: Matan Ninio, August 3, 2005 -
Risbecia pulchella from Reunion Island
From: Stefaan Dewulf, February 1, 2005 -
Risbecia pulchella from Thailand
From: Spencer Huang, December 8, 2003 -
Risbecia pulchella from Red Sea
From: Leo de Pee, May 22, 2003 -
Risbecia pulchella from the Red Sea
From: Oren Lederman, May 17, 2003 -
Chromodoris hintuanensis or R. pulchella?
From: Asther M. Lau, May 10, 2003 -
Risbecia ghardaqana from Andaman Sea
From: Mary Jane Adams, April 8, 2003 -
Risbecia pulchella from the Red Sea
From: Ilan Ben-Tov , April 8, 2003 -
Risbecia pulchella from the Andaman Sea
From: Mary Jane Adams, April 8, 2003 -
Re: Risbecia ghardaqana trailing
From: Erwin Koehler, April 8, 2003 -
Risbecia ghardaqana trailing
From: Sarah Heaney, March 29, 2003 -
Risbecia ghardaqana - 'trailing' behaviour
From: Larry Dupriest, March 2, 2003 -
Risbecia ghardaqana from sthn Thailand
From: Priscilla Yeo, January 25, 2003 -
Re: Risbecia pulchella vs. ghardaqana
From: Ron Velarde, April 6, 2002 -
Risbecia pulchella or ghardaqana (2)
From: Erwin Koehler, April 5, 2002 -
Risbecia pulchella vs. ghardaqana
From: Erwin Koehler, April 5, 2002 -
Risbecia pulchella from Bali
From: Stuart Hutchison, April 4, 2002 -
Risbecia ghardaqana from the Red Sea
From: Jim Anderson, January 31, 2002 -
Is this Risbecia ghardaqana?
From: Doug Segar, March 14, 2001 -
Risbecia pulchella - range extension
From: Michael D. Miller, March 14, 2001 -
Risbecia pulchella without gills
From: Valda Fraser, January 12, 2001 -
Risbecia pulchella from Oman
From: Gordon T. Smith, October 30, 2000 -
Risbecia from the Seychelles
From: Dick Ballendux, November 12, 1999 -
Risbecia pulchella from Thailand
From: Bill Rudman, April 12, 1999 -
'Trailing' in Risbecia pulchella
From: Bill Rudman, April 11, 1999 -
'Trailing' in Risbecia ghardaqana
From: Erwin Koehler, April 9, 1999