Variation? in Chromodoris dianae
June 25, 2001
From: Bernard Picton
Hi Bill,
These Chromodoris dianae are a small selection of the ones I have seen over the years. I have my doubts as to whether it is one variable species. While the gills in 'true' C. dianae are variable in colour and the orange pigment spots at the edge of the mantle develop from nowhere in slightly larger individuals, the form with white gill bases abruptly changing to yellow tips seems different. There are other features which distinguish it from C dianae in my opinion. I'll call it C. cf. dianae in this message for clarity. In C. cf. dianae the whitish pigment all over the mantle is not areolate as it is in C. dianae and has a different 'consistency'. There is normally a black curved line across the front of the head and a circular black spot between the rhinophores, whilst in C. dianae there is a line of black spots which develop in the midline of the back and between the rhinophores - predominantly longitudinal rather than the transverse sort of marking in C. cf. dianae. C. cf. dianae also seems to be a broader animal even given the way nudibranchs change shape as they move.
I've re-read Dave and Terry's paper and I still think there are two entities here as you suggested in an earlier message. (I don't agree completely with the way you divided Lindsay's pictures! Only the first one from Hoga is definitely C. cf. dianae by my criteria and is probably the same individual as my chrdia3. This is a tricky problem, is anyone looking at DNA or enzymes?
My pictures as follows -
chrdia - Hoga, Indonesia, 1997
chrdia1 - Hoga, Indonesia, 1997
chrdia2 - Sipadan, Malaysia - 1992
chrdia3 - Hoga, Indonesia, 1997 - C. cf. dianae
chrdia4 - Bali - 1996 - C. cf. dianae
chrdia5 - Sipadan, Malaysia - 1992
chrdia6 - Philippines, 1983
Bernard
bernard.picton.um@nics.gov.uk
Picton, B.E., 2001 (Jun 25) Variation? in Chromodoris dianae. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/4665
Thanks Bernard,
There's nothing like a good taxonomic tangle to stir the blood! Two questions arise if it turns out that there is more than one species. The first is: Which is the real C. dianae? - there is nothing in the original description to identify the colour form of the holotype. The second question is that if the variable form (not the yellow-tipped gill form) is the 'real' C. dianae, then how does it differ from some of the colour forms of Chromodoris michaeli in yesterday's message?
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman.
Related messages
-
Chromodoris dianae feeding
From: Nerida Wilson, August 1, 2007 -
Chromodoris dianae with yellow spots
From: Roberto Sozzani, February 21, 2007 -
Re: Chromodoris willani & C. boucheti
From: Bob Whorton, February 21, 2007 -
Chromodoris dianae from Malaysia
From: Mike Krampf, February 5, 2007 -
Chromodoris dianae from Nth Sulawesi
From: Mirjam Broos, January 26, 2007 -
Chromodoris dianae from Sipadan, Malaysia
From: Charles Rowe, June 14, 2006 -
Re: Another C. lochi variation? from Philippines
From: Isidro Cuallado, April 12, 2006 -
Chromodoris dianae - feeding
From: Guido & Philippe Poppe, April 10, 2006 -
Chromodoris dianae feeding?
From: Roberto Sozzani, November 12, 2005 -
Re: Chromodoris dianae feeding
From: Roberto Sozzani, February 18, 2004 -
Re: Chromodoris dianae feeding
From: Roberto Sozzani, January 29, 2004 -
Re: Chromodoris dianae feeding
From: Roberto Sozzani, January 23, 2004 -
Chromodoris dianae feeding
From: Fredy Brauchli, January 22, 2004 -
Chromodoris dianae feeding
From: Mary Jane Adams, January 15, 2004 -
Chromodoris dianae from Borneo.
From: Kheong Sann Chan, September 6, 2003 -
Chromodoris dianae from Okinawa
From: Bob Bolland, March 4, 2003 -
Re: Chromodoris dianae
From: Mark Burnett, February 15, 2003 -
Chromodoris dianae
From: Mark Burnett, February 14, 2003 -
Chromodoris dianae from Mabul Island, Malaysia
From: Richard Houghton, February 6, 2003 -
Chromodoris dianae from Philippines
From: Deanna Charlton-Jones, December 19, 2002 -
Chromodoris dianae -flattened egg ribbon
From: Mary Jane Adams, December 6, 2002 -
Chromodoris from the Moluccas
From: Ginette Allard, November 26, 2002 -
Chromodoris dianae from Sulawesi
From: Mary Jane Adams, July 6, 2002 -
Nudibranch from Sulawesi
From: Barbara Phua, June 14, 2002 -
Chromodoris dianae from Bali
From: Stuart Hutchison, March 23, 2002 -
Chromodoris michaeli? from the Philippines
From: Erwin Koehler, June 17, 2001 -
Colour forms of Chromodoris dianae
From: D. Behrens & T. Gosliner, October 18, 1999 -
More Chromodoris dianae from Sulawesi
From: Lindsay Warren , December 19, 1998 -
Chromodoris dianae from Sulawesi
From: Lindsay Warren, November 19, 1998 -
Re: Found in Indonesia
From: Lindsay Warren, April 22, 1998 -
Found in Indonesia
From: Lindsay Warren, April 8, 1998