Re: Lukot - Marine Spaghetti from the Philippines
August 3, 2006
From: Richard Parker
Concerning message #17296:
Many thanks, Bill for this answer, which has relieved me somewhat - I thought it was a much more basic secretion than that.
But that has led to another speculation:
Apparently the colour of the eggs can change according to the type of algae the sea hare has eaten recently, and can also contain toxins derived from the algae, so I'll be checking the colour is ok before I eat any more of it, and hoping the local harvesters do the same.
Filipinos eat such sea food raw, as 'kinilaw' which is 'cooked' in vinegar, and sliced onions, ginger and chili are added.
see: http://www.coconutstudio.com/kinilaw_art.htm
Could the vinegar or spices de-nature some of the toxins that such foods could contain? I note that it's also recommended as a remedy for jellyfish stings. If so, then it's a very good example of the kind of 'folk wisdom' that's fast getting forgotten.
regards
Richard Parker
richardparker01@yahoo.com
Parker, R., 2006 (Aug 3) Re: Lukot - Marine Spaghetti from the Philippines. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/17301Dear Richard,
It certainly seems that the colour of the eggs that a sea hare produces can change within 48 hours of a change in algal diet. However there is good evidence to show that secondary metabolites present in the algae [which include the distasteful, and/or noxious chemicals], are NOT transferred to the egg masses by the sea hares. This leaves the puzzle of why Sea Hare eggs are seldom, if ever, eaten by other animals. Laboratory experiments with fish and crabs show quite clearly that they reject the eggs as food. Whatever deters them doesn't seem to come from the algae, so there doesn't seem to be much point in checking the egg colour before you eat them.
Concerning the efficacy of vinegar as a home remedy for toxins and stings. All I am willing to say is that I live in Sydney where every year surfers and swimmers are regularly stung by bluebottles - the local name for Physalia - and other unidentified stingers. And every year there is a debate over whether vinegar, methylated spirits, ice, hot water, rubbing sand or even soluble aspirin on the affected skin, etc is the best cure for these stings. All I can say is the pain goes away eventually, even though new 'experts' with 'new cures' never do.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Re: Suitability of Dolabella auricularia in an aquarium
From: Jorgen Svard, March 8, 2010 -
Dolabella auricularia diet
From: Keith Teller, November 16, 2009 -
Re: Dolabella auricularia from Tonga
From: Alastair Robertson, October 13, 2009 -
Re: Marine Spaghetti from the Philippines
From: Lorraine M. Cueva, September 25, 2009 -
Unknown from Camden Haven, New South Wales
From: Samson Kwok, January 9, 2009 -
Dolabella auricularia from Mozambique
From: Valda Fraser, April 14, 2008 -
Sea hare from Port Hacking, Sydney
From: David Robertson, April 7, 2008 -
Dolabella from South Africa
From: Waldo Nell, August 16, 2006 -
Lukot - Marine Spaghetti from the Philippines
From: Richard Parker, August 1, 2006 -
Is Dolabella auricularia hermaphrodite?
From: Gary Majchrzak, July 10, 2006 -
Dolabella auricularia from Forster, NSW.
From: Colin Malakou, March 23, 2006 -
Re: Is my sea hare sick?
From: Brian Vastag, July 19, 2005 -
Is my sea hare sick?
From: Brian Vastag, July 18, 2005 -
Dolabella auricularia from Sth Korea
From: Dong Bum Koh, July 18, 2005 -
Dolabella auricularia from Natal
From: Gerda du Raan, June 6, 2005 -
Dolabella auricularia in aquarium
From: Tomoko Schum, February 8, 2005 -
Sea Hare from Hawaii
From: Lyudmila Zinkova , December 23, 2004 -
Dolabella auricularia from Sydney Harbour
From: Greg Braun, August 11, 2004 -
Re: Sea Hares
From: Tom and Jack Burrows, February 4, 2004 -
Sea slugs?
From: Tom and Jack Burrows, February 3, 2004 -
Dolabella auricularia from Red Sea
From: Isabelle Drouet, January 22, 2004 -
Suitability of Dolabella auricularia in an aquarium
From: Carolyn Bryce, December 6, 2003 -
Inking behavior in Dolabella auricularia
From: Jaron Brown, October 3, 2003 -
Dolabella auricularia in the South China Sea
From: Kheong San Chang, April 17, 2003 -
Re: Dolabella - Captive breeding
From: Cathryn Clarke, March 31, 2003 -
Dolabella auricularia captive breeding
From: Hervé, March 29, 2003 -
Dolabella auricularia from the Philippines
From: Anevi Gunday, February 6, 2003 -
Dolabella auricularia from Lord Howe Island
From: W.B. Rudman, January 30, 2003 -
Dolabella auricularia and egg masses
From: Rachel Przeslawski, January 14, 2003 -
Re: Growth stages in Dolabella auricularia
From: Alicia Hermosillo, January 4, 2003 -
Re: Growth stages in Dolabella auricularia
From: Alicia Hermosillo, January 2, 2003 -
Re: Dolabella juveniles
From: Mary Jane Adams, January 2, 2003 -
Growth stages in Dolabella auricularia
From: Mary Jane Adams , January 1, 2003 -
Dolabella auricularia in the Philippines
From: Jonathan P. Ubaldo, December 5, 2002 -
EU survey of Dolabella
From: Kim Friedman , September 23, 2002 -
Aplysiid from Bahia de Banderas
From: Alicia Hermosillo, September 13, 2002 -
About dolastatines
From: Denis Berlemont, July 6, 2002 -
Dolabella auricularia from Sth Korea
From: Dong Bum, Koh, June 28, 2002 -
Natural history of Dolabella auricularia
From: Sheena, March 5, 2002 -
Dolabella auricularia from Japan
From: Nishina Masayoshi , November 5, 2001 -
Where can we find Dolabella
From: T. Thiru, September 15, 2001 -
Chemical defense in Dolabella
From: Julia Brooke, April 8, 2001 -
Diet of Dolabella auricularia
From: Arnaud Parenty, March 28, 2001 -
Re: Dolabella auricularia and burrowing
From: Don Barclay, March 19, 2001 -
Dolabella auricularia and burrowing
From: Don Barclay, March 17, 2001 -
Dolabella auricularia - source of new drug
From: Arnaud Parenty, February 24, 2001 -
Re: Sea Hare eggs
From: Nerissa Bontia, October 14, 2000 -
Dolabella auricularia from Solomon Ids
From: Bruce Potter, October 13, 2000 -
Aplysiid egg compounds
From: Kirsten Benkendorff, September 22, 2000 -
Sea Hare eggs
From: Nerissa Bontia, September 21, 2000 -
Re: Dolabella as food
From: Claudia Armann, July 23, 1999 -
Dolabella auricularia research
From: Sandeep K. Singh, June 22, 1999 -
Dolabella egg masses
From: Erwin Koehler, April 1, 1999 -
Re:Dolabella in Fiji - as food etc
From: Veikila Vuki, March 17, 1999 -
Re:Dolabella research in Fiji
From: Sandeep K. Singh, March 16, 1999 -
Re: Dolabella in Fiji
From: Sandeep K. Singh, March 16, 1999 -
Dolabella research in Fiji
From: Dr. Veikila Vuki, March 10, 1999