Aldisa erwinkoehleri from the Andaman Sea
March 23, 2007
From: David Scheel
Bill,
I have been unable to identify the Dorids in this photograph. Are you able to? They seem likely to be Phyllidiidae based on over-all appearance (perhaps Phyllidiella or Phyllidiopsis, judging by bi-colored white and black rhinopores, orange and white tubercules, blue ground with black stripes). Unfortunately, I did not turn them over to check for medial stripe on the foot.
I have looked through images of that family on your site, however, and was unable to find a match. Phyllidia and Phyllidiella species were common on other dives I did in the Similans around the same time.
Place: Deep Six, Koh Payoo, Similan Islands, Thailand, Andaman Sea. Depth: 30 feet. Length: approximately 1-2 cm. 8 February 2007. Rocky reef
Photographer: D. Scheel
Thanks for any information you can provide.
Cheers,
David Scheel
Alaska Pacific University
dscheel@alaskapacific.edu
Scheel, D., 2007 (Mar 23) Aldisa erwinkoehleri from the Andaman Sea. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/19740Dear David,
You seem to have made a good attempt to identify these animals but you have missed one vital clue - dorsal gills. In the close-up alongside we can see a circle of gills in the posterior dorsal midline - a common feature in dorid nudibranchs, but one which is missing in all members of the Phyllidiidae.
This is the recently named Aldisa erwinkoehleri, one of a growing number of phyllidiid mimics which are being discovered [see mimicry Fact Sheet]. One reason that phyllidiids are often the most commonly seen nudibranchs - especially during daylight hours - is that they contain extremely disasteful chemicals in their mantle, which deter fish from eating them. As often occurs in nature when someone comes up with a good survival strategy, a number of dorids, often unrelated to each other, have decided to mimic phyllidiids so that they also look distasteful to hungry fish.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Aldisa erwinkoehleri from Thailand [2]
From: Marcel Tanke, February 5, 2009 -
Aldisa erwinkoehleri from Thailand, laying red eggs [1]
From: Marcel Tanke, February 5, 2009 -
Aldisa erwinkoehleri - another species update
From: Dave Behrens, March 13, 2002 -
Phyllidia-mimic from Thailand
From: Pauli Kuusisto, January 19, 2000 -
Phyllidia mimics again
From: Erwin Koehler, July 3, 1999 -
Another amazing phyllidiid mimic
From: Michael Miller , December 31, 1998