What is Filurus dubius?
February 24, 2006
From: Gary Rosenberg
Dear Bill,
I recently came across the name Filurus dubius De Kay, 1843 and am trying to figure out how to list it in Malacolog. Filurus is treated as a synonym of Glaucus at http://www.seaslug.com/systemat.html and in American Seashells (Abbott 1974) it is treated as a possible synonym of Melibe (Chioraera). The original description (DeKay, 1843 -Zoology of New York, 5: 11) says the following:
Genus Filurus.
Tentacula two. Gills in two series along the back. Vent terminal. Caudal appendage long and filiform.
Filurus dubius.
Description. Body cylindrical, enveloped in a loose transparent membrane through which the intestinal tube is apparent. Along the back are two rows of branchial? processes, six in number on each side; at their tips, furnished with five or six spiculae: these are only seen when the animal is in motion. Mouth terminal, composed of a loose festooned membrane, alternately dilating and contracting when the animal is in motion; when dilated, two small transparent tentacula are protruded. The abdomen, or upper surface, appears to be composed of numerous rings. The caudal portion becomes abruptly smaller than the body, is long, cylindrical, and tapering to a point.
Color. Abdomen silvery white; dorsal region and sides light brown; tail light greenish. The color of the body, however, appears to depend on the contained viscera.
Length of body, 0.5; of tail, 0.7 [inches].
This curious animal was taken while swimming in salt water with its body reversed. Its motion was vermicular, and it appeared to be very tenacious of life, as it lived several days in a vessel containing salt water which had not been renewed.
De Kay did not provide an illustration or state where the specimen was collected, but presumably it is from Long Island Sound, New York.
I'd appreciate any thoughts on this creatures identity.
Best wishes,
Gary Rosenberg
Department of Malacology
Academy of Natural Sciences, Philadelphia, USA
rosenberg@acnatsci.org
Rosenberg, G., 2006 (Feb 24) What is Filurus dubius?. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/15932Hi Gary,
I might as well start the day with a puzzle. I dont think this is a gastropod at all. The mention of a terminal vent [anus] immediately cancels out opisthobranchs and I presume other gastropods. If I saw this description without knowing it had been claimed as a mollusc I would have little doubt in thinking it was a polychaete. His mention of 5 or 6 spiculae which protrude from the tips of the gills when moving is to me a clear description of polychaete parapodia. Which fits with a terminal anus, seeing viscera through body wall, 'vermicular' movement, abdomen consisting of rings, etc.
One possibility is a species of Tomopteris, a planktonic genus of polychaetes some of which have a long filiform 'tail' - although they tend to have more than 6 pairs of parapodia. Another possibility is a species of Syllid worm, several of which are planktonic.
It doesn't fit Glaucus or Glaucilla which have two lobes on each side bearing cerata - no spicules and a lateral anus, and it doesn't fit any Melibe I know. Apart from shape, neither Melibe nor the related Mediterranean Tethys have been reported from the west Atlantic - they swim by lateral flexion of the body, have no spicules etc.
My suggestion would be to flick this name to the Polychaete people. I am sure it is not an opisthobranch.
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Glaucus from South Africa
From: Emil H Niksch, May 3, 2010 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Florida
From: Stephanie Armentrout, April 30, 2010 -
Glaucus atlanticus from nthn New South Wales
From: Jayson Dyer, April 23, 2010 -
Re: Glaucus atlanticus from Florida
From: Douglas Hernandez, April 6, 2010 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Florida
From: Emma C., April 5, 2010 -
Blue Bottles and Nudibranch washed up at Kiama, NSW
From: Cherie Noon, March 24, 2010 -
Glaucus atlanticus in Hawaii
From: Aaron Silva, January 29, 2010 -
Glaucus atlanticus find in Northern NSW Australia
From: Matthew Ross, January 20, 2010 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Hawaii
From: Enjoli' Hoskins, September 8, 2009 -
Occurrence of albino Glaucus atlanticus?
From: Evan Orellana, August 31, 2009 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Pacific coast of Panama
From: Clark Misner, May 14, 2009 -
My Glaucus atlanticus Report
From: Kenneth Hattersley, May 14, 2009 -
Glaucus atlanticus in Gulf of Mexico?
From: Kenneth Hattersley, April 7, 2009 -
Re: Tiny, elaborate creature at Stradbroke Island, Queensland
From: Paul Stewart, March 17, 2009 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Kenya
From: Debs North, January 8, 2009 -
Tiny, elaborate creature at Stradbroke Island, Queensland
From: Ken Thomas, December 3, 2007 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Pacific coast of Mexico
From: Joe Weiss, March 7, 2007 -
Sea Lizard [Glaucus atlanticus] from New South Wales
From: Lynne T., March 2, 2007 -
Glaucus atlanticus mating habits
From: Johanna Schwartz, January 29, 2007 -
Glaucus atlanticus in Hawaii
From: Nichol Miura, January 16, 2007 -
What type of Nudibranch is this?
From: Adrian Giles, January 15, 2007 -
Re: Glaucus atlanticus on Gold Coast, Queensland
From: Rob Alesbury, January 15, 2007 -
Glaucus atlanticus on Gold Coast, Queensland
From: John Campbell, December 14, 2006 -
Glaucus eating Porpita in Hawaii
From: Anna-Christina Amason, August 17, 2006 -
Feeding and some trophic interactions of Glaucus atlanticus
From: Irina Roginskaya, August 2, 2006 -
About egg masses of Glaucus atlanticus
From: Irina Roginskaya, May 25, 2006 -
Unknown creature from Fraser Island, Queensland
From: Richard Wilsher, May 9, 2006 -
Some notes about Glaucus atlanticus
From: Irina Roginskaya, May 9, 2006 -
Not sure if this IS a sea slug?
From: Mary Patterson, April 26, 2006 -
Glaucus at Anna Bay, New South Wales
From: Jim Doyle, March 31, 2006 -
Re: Cannibalism in Glaucus?
From: Peter Whiter, March 30, 2006 -
Cannibalism in Glaucus?
From: Peter Whiter, March 28, 2006 -
What the ?
From: Eve Whicker, March 23, 2006 -
Glaucus atlanticus - habitat
From: Brandon Pinkney, February 21, 2006 -
Is this a sea slug ??
From: Karen Beal, February 14, 2006 -
Blue Sea slug
From: Liliana Alaniz, February 2, 2006 -
Glaucus atlanticus from the Canary Islands
From: Kim Boettcher, May 23, 2005 -
Information on Glaucus atlanticus
From: Kealy Baker-Clark, April 22, 2005 -
Blue, lizard-like feather-finned tiny animal
From: Paiton Meurer, April 14, 2005 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Reunion Island
From: Philibert Bidgrain, February 19, 2005 -
Found some interesting sea slugs in Florida
From: Sarah McDowell, January 31, 2005 -
Neon Blue sea slug from Fraser Island?
From: Neil Rhodes, January 1, 2005 -
Is this a nudibranch?
From: Scott Godwin, January 21, 2004 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Sth Africa
From: Juleen du Toit, January 21, 2004 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Queensland
From: Nick Falconer , December 3, 2003 -
Glaucus from Wellington Pt, Brisbane
From: Mimi & Phong, November 17, 2003 -
Glaucus in Hawaii
From: Chaunte Ling, May 27, 2003 -
Mysterious blue and white swirley things
From: Sally, April 25, 2003 -
Re: Glaucus in Sydney
From: Alex & Marcus Dawes, March 19, 2003 -
Glaucus in Sydney
From: Alex and Marcus Dawes , March 12, 2003 -
Glaucus atlanticus from Lord Howe Island
From: W.B. Rudman, January 24, 2003 -
Glaucus atlanticus reference
From: Michael Schroedl, November 14, 2002 -
Glaucus atlanticus - observations
From: A. Lovatt., October 21, 2002 -
Thanks
From: Amanda Johnson, June 15, 2002 -
Glaucus atlanticus information
From: Manda, June 6, 2002 -
Re: Collaroy 'Blue Dragon' - thanks
From: Stephen Martin, May 23, 2002 -
Mass of blue dragon(?) nudibranchs
From: Stephen Martin, May 20, 2002 -
Questions about Glaucus
From: Luke Short, April 25, 2002 -
Blue plankton in Uruguay
From: Philip Miller, February 16, 2002 -
Glaucus from Pensacola, Florida
From: Elvira Davis, February 4, 2002 -
Re: Glaucus detecting prey
From: Belinda Biggam, March 18, 2001 -
Glaucus detecting prey
From: Belinda Biggam, March 15, 2001 -
Re: Glaucus
From: Lisa, February 20, 2001 -
Glaucus
From: Chris Parks, August 24, 2000 -
Information on Glaucus atlanticus
From: Angela, August 12, 1999 -
Eggs of Glaucus and Glaucilla
From: Bill Rudman, May 16, 1999 -
Glaucus & Porpita in New Zealand
From: Ross Armstrong, March 31, 1999 -
Re: Glaucus in New Zealand
From: Ross Armstrong, February 26, 1999 -
Glaucus in New Zealand
From: Ross Armstrong, February 25, 1999