Unknown Onchidoris from Scapa Flow, Scotland
December 2, 2009
From: Ian Smith
Dear Bill
Here are three images from Orkney that I am uncertain about. When found, I thought they were a pale form of Onchidoris sparsa, but I now have doubts as they appear so different from the specimen in my "typical O. sparsa" message [#22870].
I wonder if they might be the form of O. depressa with purple-brown spots instead of the usual orange brown, mentioned by Alder & Hancock and Thompson & Brown?
My concerns are:
1. "Glistening spicules" are clearly visible on these specimens, as described for O. depressa by Thompson & Brown, but not on my typical O. sparsa image.
2. Tubercles are difficult to discern in my pictures, but I think soft long tubercles (as described by A & H and T & B for O. depressa) show against the blue grid lines on the left-hand edge of the 10 mm specimen, about 3 mm from the posterior [upper photo].
Both species have tubercles with dark tips (Thompson & Brown); they show best over the dark gut in these photos and in my typical O. sparsa image where, seen from directly above, they appear as pale discs with very dark centres.
O. sparsa's "dorsum bears numerous small, rounded tubercles which often have a basal ring of dark pigment" (Thompson & Brown). The dark ring can be seen on my typical sparsa image, but not on these.
3. On O. sparsa "The pigmentation of the pallial epithelium around the rhinophores is usually different from the remainder, sometimes darker, more usually paler, and conspicuous pallial tubercles may arise from such areas, which may not be bilaterally symmetrical" (Farran,1903 in Thompson and Brown). All these features can be seen in my typical O. sparsa image, but none in these pictures.
I would be pleased to have the opinion of any other forum member with experience of these species.
Locality: Scapa Flow, Orkney, intertidal, Scotland, U.K., North Atlantic, 29 March 1975, Sheltered rocky shore. Length: 6 mm and 10 mm. Photographer: Ian F. Smith.
- Alder,J. and Hancock, A. 1845-1855, A monograph of the British nudibranchiate Mollusca parts 1-7, London, Ray Society
- Farran, G.P. 1903. The nudibranchiate molluscs of Ballynakill and Boffin harbours, Co. Galway. Rep. Sea and Island Fish. Ireland (1901) part 2, app. viii: 123-132.
- Thompson, T.E. and Brown, G.H. (1976) British Opisthobranch Molluscs. Linnean Society of London / Academic Press
- Thompson, T.E. and Brown, G.H. (1984) Biology of Opisthobranch Molluscs Vol 2. Ray Society, London .
Best wishes
Ian
ifsmith@bethere.co.uk
Smith, I. F., 2009 (Dec 2) Unknown Onchidoris from Scapa Flow, Scotland. [Message in] Sea Slug Forum. Australian Museum, Sydney. Available from http://www.seaslugforum.net/find/22871Thanks Ian,
This definitely requires some local knowledge. Thompson & Brown illustrate a similar looking species they identify as O. oblonga, but perhaps Greg or Bernard Picton could help us out
Best wishes,
Bill Rudman
Related messages
-
Re: Another Mediterranean mystery
From: Marina Poddubetskaia Ossokine, October 13, 2009 -
Re: Discodoris stellifera? from the Mediterranean
From: Philip Cromwell, October 12, 2009 -
Re: Discodoris stellifera? from the Mediterranean
From: Antonio Perrone, October 8, 2009 -
Re: Discodoris stellifera? from the Mediterranean
From: Dominique Horst, October 7, 2009 -
Re: Unidentified dorid from Mediterranean France
From: Sandrine Bielecki, January 21, 2009 -
Unidentified dorid from Mediterranean France
From: Sandrine Bielecki, January 20, 2009 -
Unidentified species from Norway
From: Sven Gust, June 20, 2007 -
Unknown polycerid from Malta
From: Patricia Peels, May 23, 2007 -
Hypselodoris from Malta
From: Patricia Peels, February 14, 2007 -
Hypselodoris gasconi? from the Adriatic
From: Cristian Magnani, June 2, 2006 -
Tritoniid from SE Greenland
From: Bart van Heugten, February 4, 2006 -
Dorid from Slovenia [1]
From: tom turk, October 1, 2005 -
Facelinid from Sao Tome Id., off west Africa
From: Gonçalo Calado, April 16, 2005 -
Re: Unknown species from Norway
From: Jussi Evertsen, February 20, 2004 -
Unknown species from Norway
From: Kåre Telnes, February 19, 2004 -
Flabellina from Cape Verde Islands
From: Gérard Breton, August 26, 2003 -
Pleurobranch unknown to Portugal
From: Cesar Gavaia, June 26, 2003 -
Elysia viridis? f rom Malta
From: Erwin Koehler, August 7, 2001 -
Elysia translucens from southern France
From: Jean-Pierre Bielecki , June 8, 2001 -
Aplysia from the Canary Ids
From: Erwin Koehler, April 5, 2001 -
Re: Another Mediterranean Mystery
From: Bernard Picton, September 24, 2000 -
Re: Unknown dorid from Croatia
From: Juan Lucas Cervera, July 10, 2000 -
Unknown dorid from Croatia
From: Erwin Koehler, July 2, 2000 -
Another Mediterranean mystery
From: Erwin Koehler, October 22, 1999